Photography Competition: AUGUST 2007

AUGUST 2007 - TREE or TREES

Ian - Winning Photo ____________________ _Nigel

AUGUST WINNER - IAN

Public Vote Result:- IAN 52% - NIGEL 48%

(Total Votes 82)

Independent Judge's Comments

"Both are very good photos and hard to find a winner, but taking into account the brief, I have awarded the "prize" to the one taken in daylight as it really does fulfill the criteria. It is a very unusual angle but the photograph takes the viewer into the tree and really does get the feeling of a living organism." said Ruth. ______________________________________

I decided to to set up this competition after my wedding to Renata in Poland back in July 2007. We noticed and talked about, within family and friend's circle, that my brother Nigel had all the top photographic equipment but was not sure how to use it. I thought I would push him to a much higher level in photography, photo composition and teach him a few things by challenging him to this monthly competition. It is judged by an independent and impartial person to give a completely true result each month and also put to the public vote to have their say. I hope you enjoy the photo's.

Ian x

Judging Criteria.

The first and probably the most important and critical aspect of judging the entries is whether they fulfil the competition brief. This is already decided by the competitors in this case, so the judge is working to YOUR requirements.

An example you might like to consider: The title could be "Birds" and a dictionary definition would be included saying that they are two legged, winged and feathered members of the animal kingdom. In an extreme case one competitor could take a very ordinary photograph of chickens (badly composed etc etc) and the other a really beautiful "arty" shot of Marilyn Monroe Look-a-likes.

Both would fit the bill as commonplace examples of Birds as used colloquially but one fails spectacularly to fit the brief.

Having established that they both fit the criteria then other decisions need to be made. This is more subjective and questions how well the brief has been fulfilled.

To go back to the previous example, a shot of a flock of starlings fits the description better (ie Birds plural as in the brief) than a close-up of the feathers of an owl.

It is only after this that composition, focus, use of light etc can be brought in.

To sum up, the competition brief needs to be looked at very carefully either when writing it or when interpreting it and this applies to all competitions no matter what the medium.

Kind regards,
Ruth

RULES

1. The photo being entered must be taken in the month of the competition.
2. The picture can NOT be altered/changed or enhanced but can only be cropped.
3. Photo must be submitted by e-mail on the last day of each month by 12 noon, with a short explanation of your photo for the judge.
4. The public voting will start on the following day for 1 month.
5. The totally independent judge's result will be published at the end of the public vote.
6. Each photographer is to have their photo listed in the photographers gallery as a competitor.
7. Any breach of the rules could result in being disqualified and being removed from competition.
8. The independent judge's result is final.
9. Each months subject will be published on the 1st of each month.
10. Only one public vote per photographer is allowed.

AUGUST 2007 - TREE or TREES

Photography Competition

Public Vote

Photography Competition

Labels

Results 2007

Results 2008

JUDGES PROFILE

COMPETITION PRIZE

Judging Criteria.

Contact Details